Christmas Tortilla Rollups

By Amanda


From The Pioneer Woman

I made these on my Christmas episode a couple of years ago when I had friends over to the Lodge for a cocktail party, and I just realized as I made a batch yesterday that I’d never posted them here! They’re just lovely little flour tortilla wraps like the ones you’ve had a parties since 1990, but with bright red and green “jewels” that really drive the Christmas point home. And tortilla rollups will always remind me of my best friend Hyacinth, who introduced me to the circular little wonders a long, long time ago.

They’re easy. You can make ‘em ahead. There’s nothing complicated about them.

Just watch. I’ll show you!
Lop the tops and bottoms off a red and green bell pepper, then pull out the seeds.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Slice them into very thin strips…

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Then cut them in the other direction…

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
To dice ‘em up. You want the dice to be as small as possibly so the rollups will be easier to slice, and so that there won’t be big, honkin’ pieces of pepper messing things up.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
You’ll also need some sliced green onions! I slice them pretty thin so you won’t get a huge chunk of…well, green onion.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Now, get the cream cheese ready! Two oughta be enough. Let it soften on the counter for a couple of hours first.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Then, for the top secret seasoning. Make sure you don’t share this recipe with anyone else because as I said, it’s top secret: Just sprinkle in a little less than a full packet of ranch seasoning mix. It’s what many tortilla rollups have in them, and most importantly, it’s what Hyacinth did.

Now, if ranch seasoning mix makes you want to hurt someone, you can just make your own cream cheese mixture or make your own seasoning. This is a photo from the tortilla rollup recipe I posted back in 2012, and I used green onion, basil, parsley, lemon juice, and salt and pepper. Utterly delicious!

Or you can just sprinkle in some garlic salt, paprika, and whatever else you can find in your spice cabinet.

Just make the cream cheese mixture delicious, no matter what direction you head. Just be sure not to put any colors other than green or red in it, because it will mar the Christmas color scheme, and that would simply be unconscionable!

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Okay, back to yesterday’s rollups: I also added some black pepper, just to give it a little zip.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Now it’s already time to assemble the rollups! Plop about 1/4 to 1/3 cup of the mixture right in the center…

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
And use a spatula or knife to smear it all over the surface. Get all the way out to the edges!

It’s Christmas, after all.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Now just sprinkle some of the bell pepper all over the surface…

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Followed by some green onion.

***This is a good time for me to remind you that at this point, you can put whatever you want in the tortilla rollups: chopped black olives, shaved turkey, shaved ham, jalapenos, green chiles, fresh veggies, lettuce, herbs, etc. Just make sure you can roll up the tortilla when you’re all finished!

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
And then? Just roll it up. Keep it as tight as you can while you roll it to make sure the sliced rounds look nice and neat later.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Since there’s cream cheese all the way out to the edges, the end should stick/seal perfectly.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Then just repeat with the rest of the tortillas (you should go through 5 burrito sized tortillas) and wrap the rolls individually in plastic wrap.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Then you just need to pop the rolls into the fridge for at least an hour, or up to 8 hours to allow the flavors to combine and the tortillas to slightly soften. That’s the fabulous thing about tortilla rollups: You can make them the morning of your party, then just slice them up right before you serve them.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
After they’ve chilled awhile, slice them in half…

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Then put the two halves together and slice them into circles.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
And then?

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
Onto platters they go!

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
And here you can see the benefit of sprinkling the diced peppers over the cream cheese rather than mixing them into the cream cheese. You get to see all the pure, unadulterated color, whereas if you mixed the veggies in with the cream cheese, the bits of red and green would be all messy and smeared with white, and again—that would be unconscionable.

Christmas Tortilla Rollups
You can cram/crowd them onto a platter as in the previous few photos, or you can space them out a little bit. They’re so delightful, and no one can eat just one!

Here’s the handy dandy printable.


Christmas Tortilla Rollups

Prep Time:
15 Minutes
Cook Time:


  • 2 packages (8 Ounces Each) Cream Cheese, Softened
  • 1 package Dry Ranch Dressing Mix
  • 1/2 teaspoon Black Pepper
  • 1 whole Red Bell Pepper, Seeded And Diced Finely
  • 1 whole Green Bell Pepper, Seeded And Diced Finely
  • 5 whole Green Onions, Sliced Thin
  • 5 whole Burrito-sized Flour Tortillas

Preparation Instructions

In a bowl, mix the cream cheese, 1/2 to 3/4 of the packet of ranch dressing mix (add the rest to taste), and pepper with a wooden spoon until totally combined. Divide equally among the tortillas and spread into a single layer all over the surface of each tortilla.

Sprinkle on the red and green bell pepper, as well as the green onion. Roll them nice and tight, then wrap them individually in plastic wrap. Store in the fridge for at least 1 hour or up to 8 hours.

Before serving, slice into 1/2 to 3/4 inch slices and serve on a platter.

Options: Add shaved turkey, prosciutto, ham, or any meat.

Add fresh herbs if you have them.


Latest articles

Similar articles